Trial Advocacy,

Protect patients' rights, protect patients' lives - Mary Alice McLarty

TLC is dedicated to training and educating lawyers and judges who are committed to the jury system and to representing and obtaining justice for individuals.

Pete TLC
October 18, 2012

Dear Friends:

I think most of you know that the current President of the American Association for Justice (the plaintiffs bar) is our own 2004 Trial Lawyers graduate, Mary Alice McLarty. In this election season, where lawyers who represent injured people often seem to have targets painted on their backs by the tort reformers, Mary Alice is out there fighting back. Mary Alice wrote a beautiful opinion piece for CNN about the victims of medical malpractice. She used the example of her home state of Texas to talk about how terrible the reforms there have been.

Betsy Greene

TLC '05 Grad

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/12/health/medical-malpractice/index.html

Opinion: Protect patients' rights, protect patients' lives

By Mary Alice McLarty, Special to CNN

updated 8:53 AM EDT, Fri October 12, 2012

Eliminating patients' rights is not the answer to the nation's health care problems, Mary Alice McLarty says.

Editor's note: Mary Alice McLarty is president of the American Association for Justice and a partner in McLarty Pope LLP in Dallas. She practices personal injury and civil trial law, concentrating on catastrophic injury cases.

(CNN) -- We are facing a medical malpractice crisis in our country.

More than 98,000 people die every year because of preventable medical errors. That is equivalent to two 737s crashing every day for a whole year. Preventable medical errors are the sixth leading cause of death in the United States and cost our country $29 billion a year.

Lawsuits are only a symptom of the disease. The root of the medical malpractice problem is medical malpractice itself.

The civil justice system gives families of patients who have died or have been injured by medical negligence an avenue to seek accountability. It also provides an incentive to health care providers to improve patient care. Removing that accountability and incentive leaves people at risk for more injures from negligent care.

The calls for medical malpractice reform are misguided because they center on stripping away patients' rights when they should be focused on preventing the deaths and injuries from occurring in the first place.

In his October 5 piece, Dr. Anthony Youn states that the American Association for Justice "is opposed to malpractice tort reform."

Mary Alice McLarty

We absolutely are. Not just because it violates the Constitution and is an infringement on patients' rights but, more important, because when no one is accountable, no one is safe.

Let's use my home state of Texas to see how eliminating the rights of patients -- or "tort reform" -- does not work for patients or doctors, or consumers.

In 2003, Texas passed Proposition 12, which severely limited the rights of patients by placing a $250,000 cap on non-economic damages and giving extensive immunity to emergency room doctors.

Children, stay-at-home moms and the elderly have been disproportionately impacted by this law because often they do not have substantial economic losses (i.e., lost wages or salary) from medical injuries, but their quality of life has been substantially, even permanently, diminished.

If limiting injured patients' rights actually reduced unnecessary tests and costs, Texas should have significantly lower health care costs than other states. But Texas has some of the highest health care costs and highest number of uninsured people in the country.

In fact, health care costs in Texas have increased at a higher rate than anywhere else in the country, according to a study from the University of Illinois and the University of Texas.

Not only has the cost of health care not decreased, but the quality of care has not improved, either. In July 2011, the federal Agency for Health Care Research and Quality ranked Texas health care the worst in the nation.

Lastly, one of the biggest myths of all is that doctors have flocked to Texas because of the cap on damages. It is simply not true. The number of practicing physicians in Texas was actually increasing at a faster rate before this law was passed.

This applies nationwide. The Government Accountability Office and Congressional Budget Office have both said that taking away patients' rights will not significantly lower health care costs and found no evidence of doctors running unnecessary tests to avoid lawsuits, or "defensive medicine."

Patients will not see the savings and neither will doctors. The Center for Progressive Reform, a regulatory think tank, found that "restricting lawsuits might save doctors a negligible amount on malpractice premiums but the vast majority of any savings will most certainly line the pockets of the insurance companies demanding these restrictions."

This is little more than a handout to medical malpractice insurers whose average profit margin is twice as high as 50 of the most profitable Fortune 500 companies (PDF).

Eliminating patients' rights is not the answer to our nation's health care problems. Instead, we must focus on patient safety efforts. That will undoubtedly lower costs, prevent lawsuits and save Americans' lives each year.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Mary Alice McLarty.

Voir dire, interrogating jurors by legal counsel is foundational to a fair trial. This article unpacks the voir dire process—how it screens for bias and why it is pivotal for justice. Read on to gain insights into this essential legal procedure. We also want to encourage you to learn more about how the TLC Method can help you master voir dire!

Unlocking Professional Growth: How One Attorney Transformed Her Approach Using TLC's Continuing Legal Education

Trial Lawyers College
March 25, 2024

In an ever-evolving legal landscape, staying at the forefront of legal knowledge and practice is not just an option but a necessity. This is where legal continuing education online comes into play. But what exactly does continuing legal education mean? How does it impact the professional growth of attorneys? And how can one navigate the diverse range of online CLE courses and CLE programs available today?

This comprehensive guide delves into these questions, offering a deep dive into the world of continuing legal education. It explores the significance of CLE credit, the rules governing CLE, and the benefits of unlimited access to online CLE courses. From the requirements set by the Florida Bar and the American Bar Association to the specific CLE rules in jurisdictions like West Virginia, New York, California, New Jersey, and all others, this article provides a panoramic view of the CLE landscape.

Whether you're a seasoned attorney seeking to enhance your practice or a law student curious about the path ahead, this article promises to be an engaging and informative read. So, are you ready to unlock your professional growth with legal continuing education online? Let's dive in.

Transforming My Legal Practice: Mike Smith's Journey with the Trial Lawyers College

Trial Lawyers College
March 4, 2024

Imagine stepping into the courtroom, your heart beating with anticipation yet steadied by confidence. This isn't just a fleeting daydream but a reality for attorney Mike Smith, a dedicated personal injury and workers' compensation attorney from Atlanta, Georgia. His transformative journey with the Trial Lawyers College (TLC) has reshaped his approach to law and professional identity.

Protect patients' rights, protect patients' lives - Mary Alice McLarty

Recommended

Master the Voir Dire Process: Essential CLE Guidance for Attorneys from TLC

Unlocking Professional Growth: How One Attorney Transformed Her Approach Using TLC's Continuing Legal Education

Transforming My Legal Practice: Mike Smith's Journey with the Trial Lawyers College

Trending

Transforming My Legal Practice: Mike Smith's Journey with the Trial Lawyers College

Unlocking the Power of Juror Communication: A TLC Alum's Review of How TLC's CLE Impacted His Communication Skills

Unleashing the Power: Regional Seminar Empowers Women Trial Lawyers

Unlock Your Potential at the Trial Skills Foundation Course in Tulsa, Oklahoma

Empowering Women in Law: The Trial Lawyers College Experience

Protect patients' rights, protect patients' lives - Mary Alice McLarty

Recommended

Get All Our Stories in One Daily Email

Trending

Forgot Password

Verify One Time Password

Update Password

Lawyer of the People Certification

TLC Login

The TLC Legal Archive

The TLC Warrior Magazine Subscription